Trump makes Israelis look weak by ban

Benjamin Netanyahu says he had no choice but to forbid two members of Congress from visiting Israel. Israeli law bans those who boycott it, and after reviewing the itinerary of Reps. Ilhan Omar and Rashida Tlaib, the Israeli prime minister determined their visit’s “sole purpose was to support boycotts and deny Israel’s legitimacy,” according to his statement to the press. What else could he do?
In the narrowest possible sense, Netanyahu has a point. Omar, Tlaib and other Jacobins in the Democratic Party single out Israel for special opprobrium. Unlike another recent Democratic Party delegation, they had not planned to meet either government officials or members of the opposition.
In a more meaningful sense, however, Netanyahu’s statement is hogwash. First, it cannot have been a surprise that Omar and Tlaib were not traveling to Israel to get on-the-ground policy briefings. For these lawmakers, Israel is merely a prop they can use to rouse their supporters.
More important, as Axios reported this week, Israeli agencies discussing the visit had already agreed to allow the visit. Israel’s ambassador in Washington, Ron Dermer, also had said that Israel would allow the Omar-Tlaib delegation out of respect for Congress. Everyone knew this was a stunt.
So what happened between that meeting and Netanyahu’s decision? The answer is what happens to many well-laid plans: President Trump tweeted.
On Wednesday morning he said on Twitter that it would “show great weakness” for Israel to allow entry to Omar and Tlaib. And within a few hours Netanyahu gave his statement about their itinerary and Israeli law.
Yet Trump’s message — that it showed strength for Israel to ban Omar and Tlaib — is contradicted by the events it set in motion. By reversing its decision following a powerful friend’s protests, Israel looks weak.
Forget for a moment the specifics of Omar and Tlaib’s positions on issues integral to Israel. Deciding who can and cannot visit one’s country is elemental to national sovereignty. Israel has surrendered that sovereignty in this instance because Trump wants to elevate Omar and Tlaib as a foil for his own domestic political reasons.

To continue reading, log into your account or explore our subscription options:





More Columns/Opinion

Columns/Opinion
Disease can be financially toxic
For three decades Ive worked with people who are aging or chronically ill, helping them figure out how the heck they are going to pay for old age or serious illness.
September 13, 2019 - 7:41 am
Columns/Opinion
Black Americans are doing a lot better under Trump
The August jobs report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics showed more great news for all Americans.
September 12, 2019 - 7:53 am
Columns/Opinion
Is it ethical to take good money from bad people?
The now-former head of the Massachusetts Institute of Technology Media Lab went from hero to zero in a couple of news cycles.
September 11, 2019 - 8:09 am
Columns/Opinion
Dealing with Taliban devil that’s waiting us out
President Trump was right to cancel a secret meeting with leaders of the Taliban and the Afghan government following two bomb attacks by the terrorist group that killed 10 civilians, an American soldier and a Romanian service member in heavily fortified Kabul.
September 10, 2019 - 8:39 am